I heard footsteps behind me in the sanctuary. I was focusing on filling the Baptismal pool, and assumed it was one of the Brothers walking out and leaving for the day. I didn’t bother to look behind me. It wasn’t until a soft voice spoke to me that I realized it wasn’t one of the Brothers. It was a voice I instantly remembered. “Hello Fr. Mason! Long time no see,” she smiled. I turned around and was greeted by a former student of mine. Elania attened the very prestigious Catholic school I taught at for years. I had actually retired not too long after she left. I hadn’t seen her since she walked across the stage on graduation day. She had grown up to be such a beautiful young woman. I figured at this point she had to be 24 or 25. She hugged me tightly as I asked her how she’d been. She went on and on about how college went, how her mother had moved cities, and how she was planning her wedding with her high school sweetheart. For the most part, I was very happy for her. I always thought she was a sweet girl and it seemed that hadn’t changed. What did change; however, was how she looked. First off, her body was different. Of course, I never looked at her in that way while she was in school, that would have been unspeakably wrong and I’m not that type of person, but I couldn’t help but notice her breasts had grown quite a lot since she graduated. She was quite a small girl, so it wasn’t hard for them to be noticeable. As she turned around to walk towards the pews, I noticed her breasts weren’t the only things that grew. Her clothing style had also changed. She was currently wearing a baby pink button-down blouse and floral aline skirt, with a white cardigan draped over her shoulders. She was also wearing a pair of white high-heeled Mary Janes. Her hair was done up in curls and her makeup was light and pretty. This was definitely something new. Though every student was required to wear uniforms, the school did give the children a bit of leeway to express themselves fashion wise. She was very obviously gothic or alternative or whatever you called it back then. She wore heavier black eye makeup and had as many piercings as she could without violating the rule book. Her hair was also always a bit messy too, like she had just rolled out of bed. The woman standing in front of me was the complete opposite of the girl I knew before. If not for her voice, her sweet, calming voice, I might not have recognized her. After letting her ramble on and on for a few minutes, I finally asked her why she was here. Of course, I didn’t mean it in a bad way, but as I said, I hadn’t seen her since graduation 7 years ago. Also, she never seemed to be interested in Catholicism. I knew she came from a religious background, but she never seemed to care for all the Catholic ways and traditions. Her fiance; however, came from a strict Catholic family. I could only assume that their being close to marriage is why she’s converted.
“I’m here for confession, Father. Patrick wanted me to do this before our marriage. He thought it’d be a great idea to do this so we went into our marriage with “clean hearts” he called it. Patrick was an interesting kid, to say the least. He was a star athlete while in school. He excelled in several different sports. He started dating Elaina when she was a freshman and he was a sophomore. They were always the talk of the school, not necessarily for good reasons. Rumors had gone around several times about his infidelity and him just flat-out not treating her nicely. The two of them always seemed to be complete opposites. I know they say opposites attract, but they erred on the side of polar. It never seemed like they had anything in common. I never understood how their relationship worked. Not to mention, there were also rumors that he made her do things around the school, things that would’ve gotten them expelled if they were ever officially caught. I began to remember all the times after school Eliana would sit in my office her senior year. Patrick at that point was in college. Her father, who had been sickly since before she started high school, had finally succumbed to illness early into her final year. Because she didn’t have many friends and her boyfriend was in a different state, I told her she was free to stay in my office at any point during and after school hours if she needed to be alone. This is where I learned that the rumors of Patrick’s terrible behaviors were indeed true. It might be wrong to say, but I always hoped the two of them would break up. I always felt she deserved something better.
The confession started like any other. She confessed to things like the little white lies she had told and the very few times she cut a person in line at the store. I couldn’t help but laugh to myself. She was so innocent, I couldn’t help but find it adorable. Just when I started to think this, her confessions became more and more the opposite. She confessed to having premarital sex with Patrick. I had assumed this years ago based on the type of boy Patrick was. She also confessed to pleasing him orally around the high school, which confirmed the rumors I heard back then. She even confessed to masturbating. I’m not quite sure what started to come over me, but my mind began to wander. I began to think of her doing all these things, especially her touching herself. I wondered what her body looked and felt like. How her body reacted to certain touches. I started to feel myself growing underneath my clothes. I was honestly ashamed. She also confessed to having sinful sexual thoughts in general. She didn’t go into detail, but I was well aware of what that school taught students. They were taught that sex wasn’t for pleasure, only procreation between a married man and a woman. They were taught that enjoying unconventional things in the bedroom meant you weren’t pure and you were going to hell. Even though I thought this was all ridiculous and a bit too far, I never said anything. Her last confession kind of shocked me. She confessed to having sinful thoughts about other men who weren’t Patrick, but again she didn’t go into detail. I guess this shocked me because I knew everything he put her through. I had no clue she still felt some guilt about this. Honestly, this made me feel worse about their relationship. The joy in her voice when she walked in was gone. Her voice was soft and meek. I could tell she was shy and ashamed. I wrapped my arm around her shoulder to comfort her. I told her that she was forgiven and that everything would be ok. She smiled up at me before thanking me. She chuckled before shyly admitting she had another confession. “If I’m being honest, Father, I used to have the hugest crush on you when I was in school. You were definitely the hot teacher to me.” I was quite taken aback. I was a lot older than her. I had been teaching at the school for probably thirty years by the time she started high school. I was already completely gray by the time I met her. Growing up, I was told by girls all the time I was good-looking, but I never gave it much thought. Once I turned gray, I definitely never gave much thought to whether I was attractive or not. She looked at me nervously, as if I was going to be disgusted by what she just said, especially since I did visibly look shocked. I patted my hand in her lap gently, assuring her it was ok. Her face turned red just from that little touch. She put her hand on top of mine, rubbing it softly. “Would this be a bad time to also confess that some of those sinful thoughts were about you, Father. Some of those thoughts are still about you if I’m being completely honest.” I readjusted in my seat. The hardness I felt in my pants earlier was back again at full force. I smiled slyly before saying, “Of course not, my darling Eliana. Though, I would venture to say I won’t honestly know if it’s bad unless you tell me every single thought you’ve had.” I squeezed her thigh a little for encouragement. “Well Father, I can’t begin to tell you all the times I imagined you coming into your office and kissing me for starters. Sometimes, I would imagine you doing more things to me. Touching me, groping me, even taking my virginty.” I could tell her body wasn’t sure how to react. I could tell by her movements and her hardening nipples poking through her shirt she was becoming turned on. I could tell by her red face that she was extremely nervous to share these fantasies with me, understandably so. I could also tell in her voice there was still a sense of shame. I knew this was wrong, I knew this was all wrong, but for some reason, I couldn’t stop myself. I was in too deep. I wasn’t thinking with my brain anymore. I couldn’t tell you the last time I had a very attractive woman telling me how badly she wanted me. I had joined the church at 23 for several reasons. I assure you I didn’t always live a religious and pure life. It had been roughly 42 years since I had slept with someone, 42 years since I’d touched someone in that way, 42 years since I had been this hard. I allowed my hand to rub up and down her thigh before settling at the top of her thigh. She asked me nervously what I was doing. It was obvious this touch went from being one of encouragement to one of a sexual nature. I took a deep breath, realizing what I was about to do. I mumbled under my voice, “Please forgive me,” before kissing her. I was much taller and heavier than her, so when I leaned in it pushed her back. She tried to push me off of her. She tried to fight. I pulled her back up to a sitting position before dragging her onto my lap. As I felt her ass in my lap I could feel my cock get even harder. I knew that I wasn’t going to let her leave here until it was drained. I grabbed her by the neck, speaking to her softly as I choked her. “You’re ashamed of these thoughts, right? You want to stop having them, hmm? This is the only way to make them stop. You want to be pure again? Let me do this. Let’s do this.” She wiggled around in my lap in an attempt to get air and to get away from me. Though I was in my mid-60s, I still was strong and was still this tiny little girl. She knew deep inside she wouldn’t be able to get away. I tightened my grip around her throat before using my other hand to grope her tits. “These have grown so much since the last time I saw you. Tell me, are they real or did your sorry excuse for a fiance tell you to get them? You know, I never liked him. Pardon my language, but he was always an asshole. You always deserved better.” She was choking out little pleas at this point, begging me to stop, telling me this wasn’t what she wanted. She was a very nice girl in high school, but she wasn’t smart. She was dumb and naive. She was a fucking idiot if she thought that I didn’t know what her true intentions were. I heard from Partick and the other boys back when they were in school was that she was a tease.This was quickly also being proven. I moved the hand I had on her breast down to her skirt. I began to roughly pull it up. As I trailed my hands up her inner I groaned knowing exactly where I was going. Her cunt was hot and her panties were soaked. I forced her legs apart as she struggled. I moved her panties aside before running my big, long, rough fingers against her cunt. It was swollen, hairless, and dripping wet. I ripped my hand from under her skirt, shoving my fingers in her face. “You want me to stop? You want me to stop? These wet fingers tell me otherwise. Tell me, sweetheart, do you have another confession to make? Are you lying to me right now?” She shook her head no with fear. Now I see why she was at confession, she was a fucking liar. I threw her off my lap onto the ground. I stood up, towering over her young, smaller, fragile body as she trembled in fear. She looked delicious. I wanted to take her right then and there, but I had 42 years of pent-up sexual frustration and sadistic thoughts flooding out of me at once. I needed to take them all out on her. I couldn’t just fuck her immediately. I need to draw this out, make up for the last 42 years. I reached down and grabbed her by her prim and proper hair. I dragged her to the Baptismal pool, positioning her right above the water. I kneeled down behind her, pinning her between me and the pool. Even on my knees, I was still taller than her. I grabbed her under the chin, focusing her on her reflection in the water. I whispered in her ear asking if she could see our reflections in the water. When she shook her head yes, I smiled. “So, you also see this dirty lying whore and this holy man? Do you see what you’ve made me do? Your temptation and sinful thoughts have released something in me I haven’t felt since before your own mother was born.” I started to run my free hand over her body, groping and feeling different parts. “You did need this confession. You needed to confess to being a dirty slut, temptation and sinful-filled dirty slut. This is why you came to me, wasn’t it? You wanted me to fall into your temptation. You wanted me to fulfill your disgusting, depraved fantasies. I wonder how long you’ve thought about this. How long did it take for you to come up with this little plan of yours? Tell me, little girl, are you finally getting what you wanted? And don’t you fucking lie to me. Look at yourself. Look at our reflections and admit to me this is what you wanted.” I could see her tears hitting the water. Without thinking, I grinded against her ass. Something about this sweet, innocent girl who used to trust me now kneeling here crying in fear because of me made me feral. She shook her head no, lying to me yet again. I yelled, “Wrong answer, whore,” before shoving her face in the water. I kept her down for a few moments before pulling her up. She gasped for air. She was too out of breath to scream. I pushed her head under again, reveling in the fact the more she struggled the more she rubbed against me. I yanked her head back up once again, making her look at her reflection again. “You see what happens when you lie? You drown yourself in sin. You don’t want that, do you, doll? So admit it. Fucking admit THIS is why you’re here. You wanted to tempt me. You wanted me to fuck you.” I slip my hand under her skirt and panties again. I ripped her panties down her thighs, before feeling how much wetter she is now. What a disgusting little whore. Without warning, I shoved two fingers into her cunt. She gasped loudly, but she didn’t tell me no or to stop. All she did was cry, but luckily for her, her makeup was already ruined from being under the water. I fingered her slowly watching her facial expression in the water. “You’re enjoying this, look at you. These crocodile tears don’t faze me, sweetheart. I know the truth.” I shove her head under one more time, before standing up. I turned her around while still on her knees. I commanded her to look up at me, which she did immediately. “What a beautiful sight. You know, I never imagined all those times I saw you on your knees praying I’d see you on your knees about to take this holy, older cock down your throat.” Her eyes widened as she shook her head no. I shoved my wet fingers in her mouth. “You’re telling me no but these wet fingers tell another story. Why are you telling me no when THIS is what YOU wanted? We both know you’re not pure. You’re not a virgin. This isn’t your first time taking a cock down your throat. Hell, it was common knowledge the things Patrick made you do in the stairwell and behind the stage in the gym. Tell me, was he the one who made you do those things, or did you tempt him too? I wanted to give you the benefit of the doubt because I truly always thought you were an innocent, good girl. When I would hear Patrick and his friends and all the other boys in school saying how you were such a tease, I never believed it. I assumed Patrick was spreading lies about you to keep you close. Maybe he wasn’t lying after all. Now, stop your crying and open your fucking mouth. I unzipped my pants, pulling out my rock-hard cock. Her eyes lit up like it was the biggest thing she’d ever seen. She opened her mouth slowly before taking me into her mouth. “Hey! Look at me. Look me in the eyes. Don’t stop looking up at me. And make sure you get this big cock all the way down that slutty throat of yours.” I shove my cock all the way down her throat. She gagged and sputtered around my cock, but she didn’t flail around. I knew she had an experienced throat. I pulled out a little. I wanted to see her work for it. She bobbed her head up and down my cock. I wrapped my hands in her now messy and wet hair for leverage. My groans echoed through the sanctuary. She began to pick up speed and take me deeper and deeper, but it wasn’t enough. I was hungry. I held her head firm before fucking her throat. Hearing her gags echo only added to the experience. I bottomed out in her throat and held it. She looked up at me with fear in her eyes. I spat in her face before grabbing her nose to cut off her air. I had no real reason to do this, other than I enjoyed seeing her cute little face disgusted and horrified. I pulled out of her mouth completely, mostly so I wouldn’t blow my load too fast. She coughed and coughed, trying to catch her breath. She managed to choke out a “please stop,” which earned her a slap to the face. She hit the floor hard. I straddled her back, grabbing her throat and choking her as hard as I could. “I’m tired of your lies, whore. I’m tired of you telling me no. This was your idea. These are the fantasies you rubbed your disgusting little cunt to every night.” I let go of her throat, letting her catch her breath. I got off of her before standing her up. I slapped her again, but this time she didn’t fall. I kissed her again, shoving my tongue in her mouth. My tongue explored her mouth for a few moments, before telling her to strip for me. I watched in amusement as her thoroughly water an drool soaked blouse hit the floor, followed by her skirt. Her bra was next to come off, followed by her panties that I had already partially pulled down. She already looked thoroughly used based on her face and hair, but I was nowhere near done with her. I sat her down on one of the pews, continuing to take in the view of her body. She attempted to close her legs and cover her tits with her hands. I rolled my eyes before moving her hands. I started biting and sucking her left nipple while twisting and pulling her right. She let out soft little moans as I played with her. As I switched tits, I came up with an idea. I began leaving little hickies and love bites on her tits. She tried to protest, telling me how upset Patrick would be and how she wouldn’t be able to explain how she got them, but I didn’t care. It wasn’t my problem, and I couldn’t stand him anyway. I stood back admiring my work for a few seconds before working my way down. I pried her still closed legs open before lowering down to my knees. Without hesitation I dived into her completely soaked cunt. She wrapped her hands in my hair, enjoying the way my tongue flicked her clit. I went between sucking, flicking, and biting her clit. She began grinding against my face eagerly and desperately. “What, does Patrick not eat your cunt like this or are you just so happy to finally be living your filthy fantasies?” She looked down at me with pleading eyes, silently begging for me to keep going. I slapped her clit twice before going back to sucking and licking it. Her moans grew louder and louder. Her desperation grew more and more obvious. “I want you to cum in my mouth, slut. Be the filthy fucking whore you are and cum in my mouth.” I began fingering her with two fingers again while sucking on her clit. It didn’t take long for her to start trembling and moaning at the top of her lungs. I stood up before putting her in the position I was going to take her in. I made her kneel on the floor, her arms on the seat of the pew. I slapped her ass a couple times, turning it bright red. I pulled my pants down just enough to completely free my cock. I got down behind her, rubbing my cock in her wetness and teasing her hole. “So darling, am I fulfilling your twisted little fantasies just how you always dreamed or is this even better than you ever imagined?” She didn’t say anything, she only let out pathetic little whimpers. “Oh dear, I thought you were finally going to be completely honest. I was being extremely patient with you. Why must you be so difficult? Being a lying, deceiving, temptation filled whore will get you damned to hell. I’m simply trying to save your ruined soul by trying to give you what you wanted, but I see it’s not enough. I was going easy on you, doing things I’m sure you rubbed that greedy cunt of yours to the thought of. Maybe it’s time I do something to show you how serious this situation is and how important it is to be honest.” I pinned her down to the pew with one hand, which caused her to start struggling immediately. “Too late, whore. This is what girls like you get. This is what they deserve.” I used my free hand to rub some of her drippings on my cock before lining it up with her asshole. I began slowly pressing myself in, which led her to start screaming. “No, Father! Please no! I’m a virgin there! Please Father, I’m sorry! I’m a liar! I wanted this to happen. I wanted you to use me. I wanted you to fix me. Help me to repent, Father, but please, please don’t!” Tears were steady streaming down her face. Her light crying turned to desperate, pleading sobs, but I didn’t care. I knew what she needed. My mind was completely made up. I shoved my cock all the way into her ass, causing her to scream through her sobs. I didn’t hold back, fucking her roughly and deeply from the beginning. “You see Eliana, this is what happens to evil little girls that try to be like Jezebel. Just like Jezebel you get to feel intense pain, pain you fucking desevere. Sure, I’m not going to throw you to the dogs like she was, but who knows what’ll happen to you if you keep living like this. You strolled in here looking like such a sweet, modest, innocent girl. You looked like a good girl that follows God, but it was all a front. You needed to see me. Not just to fulfill these disgusting desires, but to teach you a lesson. Lucky for you honey, I like you. I care enough about you to show you what could happen to very, very bad girls. I knew you weren’t the smartest girl in your class, but I believed in you. I had a soft spot for you. I knew you had been through a lot. I’m not shocked you’re this filled with sin, but I’m going to help you now.” I fucked her harder and deeper. I knew I was ruining the poor girl’s asshole, but she had brought this situation upon herself. I had no remorse. I didn’t feel bad in the slightest. She was getting what she wanted as far as I was concerned. Truly, I wouldn’t be surprised if she imagined me raping her little virgin asshole too. I picked up my pace even more, growing closer and closer to cumming. I held her by her hips, trying to get as deep as I could. She wasn’t fighting anymore. She laid there silently crying to herself. I told her she needed to start praying, to start asking for forgiveness, start repenting. I also told her she needed to pray for my forgiveness for making me break my vow of celibacy because of her. Just to teach her this crucial, life saving lesson. I could feel myself right on the edge, seconds away from cumming. I buried myself as deep as I possibly could. I groaned as I filled her ass, reminding her this was all her fault. I slowly pulled out of her, examining the load I left in her now ruined hole. “You should be thanking me. I took those fantasies away from you. I filled you with something holy again, something that will drown out all the sins in you. I didn’t have to do this, but again, Eliana, I like you. I don’t want you being damned to Hell for eternity. I think that you need to come to me every day until your wedding. You can continue to confess your sins daily. I can find ways for you to curb those horrible thoughts. I can save you. As a matter of fact, I want to officiate you and Patrick’s wedding. I want you here hours before the wedding so I can make sure you’re completely saved and healed from those thoughts. I don’t want you carrying these wicked and unholy thoughts into your marriage, even if I don’t like him. Now, you need to clean yourself up,” I say as I grabbed her panties from off the floor. I used them as a rag to clean off my cock before tossing them back in her direction. I pulled my pants up, readjusting my clothes. I check my clock before smirking, “You should hurry up. The Brothers are going to start filing back in from work soon. You wouldn’t want them to see what happened to you, would you? You wouldn’t want them to see what happens to a whore like you in real life. It’d be a shame if all of them had to use you too to teach you a lesson. Plus, I’m sure your fiance is waiting for you at home. Feel free to use the water in the pool to clean yourself off. Same time tomorrow, my darling Eliana, if you want to be saved like you claim you want to be.” I gave her one last look before walking back to my office. I slumped down in my chair out of breath. I began to pray and repent for what I had just done. I was interrupted by a knock on the door. When I looked up, it was Eliana, now all dressed, but still messy. Her shirt was still wet and her hair and makeup were still ruined, of course. She hurried into my office, kneeled down in front of me, and bowed. “Thank you, Father. Thank you for caring enough about me to help me.” She looked up at me before kissing my hand and standing up. I pulled her down to me to kiss her, again allowing my tongue to explore her mouth. “As long as you have some part of me in you, my fingers, tongue, cock, cum, spit, you’ll be closer and closer to being saved. Now, hurry along, my child, I’ll see you tomorrow,” I say slapping her ass. I watched her walk out of my office knowing this was only just the beginning of saving her poor soul.